NTUPC x Notion 3.0 Ideathon - Judging Results

Judge: AI Judge (Claude Sonnet 4.5)

Date: January 23, 2026

Status: Pre-Pitch Scoring (Subject to adjustment after in-person presentations)

Executive Summary

After comprehensive analysis of all 7 finalist submissions, I've scored each team across the four weighted criteria: Problem Clarity (30%), Creativity & Innovation (30%), Feasibility & Execution (30%), and Presentation Delivery (10%). The pre-pitch scores below reflect only the first three criteria, as Presentation Delivery will be scored after the in-person pitches. Scores range from 1-10, with clear differentiation between submissions to reflect varying levels of sophistication, evidence, and execution.

Preliminary Rankings (Pre-Pitch):

  1. OptiMeal by Team LocalHoster - 7.80/10
  2. Student Founder OS by Team Jamuludin - 7.50/10
  3. The Problem Kanban Board by Notion Navigators - 6.60/10
  4. Context-Aware Learning Workspace by Team Synapse - 5.70/10
  5. Unified Capture Engine by Team Decidedly - 5.70/10
  6. Date our Dates by Team Dates that Stick - 5.10/10
  7. Creator Command Center by Deep Roast Oolong Tea - 4.80/10

Note: Final rankings will be determined after adding Presentation Delivery scores (10% weight) from tomorrow's in-person pitches.

Results Summary

Pre-Pitch Scores (90% of total - excludes Presentation Delivery)

Rank Team Problem Clarity (30%) Creativity (30%) Feasibility (30%) Presentation (10%) Pre-Pitch Score
1 OptiMeal by Team LocalHoster 9/10 8/10 9/10 TBD 7.80/10
2 Student Founder OS by Team Jamuludin 8/10 9/10 8/10 TBD 7.50/10
3 The Problem Kanban Board by Notion Navigators 8/10 7/10 7/10 TBD 6.60/10
4 Context-Aware Learning Workspace by Team Synapse 7/10 6/10 6/10 TBD 5.70/10
5 Unified Capture Engine by Team Decidedly 6/10 6/10 7/10 TBD 5.70/10
6 Date our Dates by Team Dates that Stick 5/10 6/10 6/10 TBD 5.10/10
7 Creator Command Center by Deep Roast Oolong Tea 5/10 5/10 6/10 TBD 4.80/10